The Conservancy testified on two issues at the LPC in September. We supported designation of the Jacob Day Residence at 50 West 13th Street as an individual landmark. The Greek Revival-style row house merits this honor for both its history and architecture. It’s nearly 180 years old and retains its historic height, massing, composition, and some details.
It was also a focus of New York’s African-American history. Jacob Day, a prominent 19th-century Black businessman and abolitionist, lived at 50 West 13th from 1858 until his death in 1884. In the mid-20th century, the building was partly converted for theater use. The Afro-American Folklore Troupe had a residency there in 1968. It was the home of the “off-off-Broadway” 13th Street Repertory Company from 1972 until 2020.
Since the theater closed, the house has faced an uncertain fate, but its distinct architecture and remarkable history make a clear argument for landmark recognition. The Commissioners were very receptive to this designation but have not yet scheduled a vote.
We supported a reactivation of the famed “Manny Hanny” Building (formerly ) but asked the Commissioners to minimize changes to this landmark at the corner of Fifth Avenue and 43rd Street. Skidmore, Owings & Merrill’s 1954 International Style icon features glass curtain walls that allow full views of the landmarked interior.
Since the bank closed and the 2011 interior designation, several retailers have made alterations to accommodate new stores. Some of these have been successful, such as the return of sculptures designed for the building, while others have diminished significant features, and blocked views of the interior.
The application in front of the LPC last month called for the installation of new signage, LED displays, and retail fixtures. We asked that all of them be scaled back, to let this singular building speak for itself. The Commissioners asked for changes which will come back to a public meeting.